Passing (1929) by Nella Larsen, written and set during the Harlem renaissance, is a complex novel, which as its name suggests, navigates themes of race and identity which form a central thread in the book but also much more, for themes of marriage and relationships are also key, besides others like motherhood, class and society.
Divided into three parts, the story is told in third person through the perspective of Irene Refield, an African–American woman who lives in Harlem with her husband Brian, a doctor, and two sons. On a visit to Chicago where her parents live, Irene is out shopping one extremely hot day when she feels faint and is ‘rescued’ by a passing taxi driver. She asks to be taken to the Drayton hotel for tea; being light skinned, Irene can ‘pass’ as white and is seen as such by most, and takes advantage of this. Here she comes across a beautiful and attractive woman who turns out to be her childhood friend Clare Kendry. Also light skinned, Clare who had a difficult childhood, is now married to a white man, one who doesn’t know her true identity; in fact John Bellew claims to hate black people and thinks his wife, whom he ‘jokingly’ calls ‘Nig’ does so too. Having severed all ties to her past, Clare’s been leading a life that’s given her all she dreamt of but now something makes her want to reconnect with her past, with the community that she’s left behind. Clare as Irene sees her is
Catlike. Certainly the word which best described Clare Kendry, if any single word could describe her. Sometimes she was hard and apparently without feeling at all; some times she was affectionate and rashly impulsive. And there was about her am amazingly soft malice, hidden well until provoked. Then she was capable of scratching, and very effectively, too.
Clare, Irene learns has travelled to Chicago with her husband specifically to run into someone from her past, to find out what has become of old friends and connections, and doesn’t seem to care how dangerous this may be for her. She is
Stepping always on the edge of danger. Always aware but not drawing back or turning aside. Certainly not because of any alarms or feeling of outrage on the part of others.
Very beautiful and with a way of making others fall in with her wishes, Clare soon works her way into Irene’s life and society, with every occasion raising her confidence, despite the threat of her secret being found out always hanging over her.
Irene herself is both intrigued by Clare and at the same time also wants constantly to break away and have nothing to do with her. Alongside, she is coping with the issues her own life and family throw up, from the upbringing of her children to the restlessness of her husband.
Passing was an engaging and multifaceted novel which while exploring the themes I had expected from its title, also proceeded in an unexpected direction adding to its substance and surprise. Our story is primarily explored through the two main characters, Irene and Clare. We learn of Clare’s childhood, her marriage, her daughter, and her desire to once again become part of her community in any way she can, but essentially it is through Irene’s eyes and descriptions that we see her. We see her certainly as Irene puts it, ‘always on the edge of danger’, but one does also wonder about the ‘real’ her.
Alongside, Irene presents an equally complex picture as while on the surface she is a happily married woman, with two children, living a fairly affluent life (‘that’s what everybody wants, just a little more money’) in Harlem, and working in the interests of her people, she has several problems and insecurities of her own. It soon emerges that Brian, despite loving his wife and family has had a long-standing desire to live and work in Brazil, something that Irene has been successfully checking; also it seems that they aren’t quite on the same page with the upbringing of their two boys. These lead to constant worries and anxiety on Irene’s part which takes her thoughts in several directions. Whether her fears are only in her mind or whether there is any truth to them, one can only guess.
Both Irene and Clare live ostensibly stable, happy lives, one ‘passing’ when the need arises but otherwise happy and comfortable with her identity, the other in a more permanent state of ‘passing’, living a ‘dream’ life, yet one where any hint of her secret can ruin all she has created for herself. Yet below the surface both are perhaps equally restless and uneasy in their own ways, and it is this that defines the plot as much as does the question of race and identity.
This is a book which though told seemingly straightforwardly leaves much to the reader’s interpretation, which for me made it a compelling read. And that ending—not only did I not see it coming (despite the tension building up in a way), but it had me reading it over again to see how it should be understood, as well as reassess what I’d been thinking of the story and characters once again.
At 141 pages, this qualifies for Novellas in November and is my first entry for that challenge.
I came across this book through Whispering Gums‘ wonderful review.
Excellent review, Mallika. You’ve made me think about this quietly powerful novella all over again.
LikeLike
Thank you Susan; it was indeed a powerful little book.
LikeLike
Great review! It’s so good, isn’t it? I found it definitely had layers I hadn’t expected and I loved the way she explored the public face we put on and also women’s issues in general. Brilliant book.
LikeLike
Thank you 🙂 Yes, I found the different threads and layers very surprising since I’d expected it to be centered entirely on the race thread; and I agree, so very good.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I haven’t heard of this one, but it sounds really interesting. Thank you for describing it so beautifully, Mallika.
LikeLike
Thank you Jan 🙂 Its an excellent read with plenty of surprises. Definitely recommended.
LikeLike
Wow, this sounds like a beautiful and compelling story. Wonderful review, Mallika!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thanks so much Wendy 🙂 It certainly was.
LikeLike
I read this last October (just before the film adaptation came out) and it ended up being one of my highlights of the year. As you say, Larsen leaves enough space for the reader to think through the issues and come to their own conclusions about various aspects of the narrative, especially the ending. It’s good to be reminded of it here.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Oh, I’d no idea there was a film version. Must look it up. Thanks for mentioning it.
One only realises later consciously that we’ve really been seeing everything through one pair of eyes, so perhaps we need to rethink things over.
LikeLike
It’s on Netflix, directed by Rebecca Hall. A very good adaptation, I think.
LikeLike
I really enjoyed your write up of this book Mallika, and thanks so much for the link.
You are right about the ending. An ending like that is a reason why I hate the fact that in blogging – unlike in a reading group – we can’t talk about endings because with some books how we read the ending is so critical to what we see as the meaning. Anyhow, I’m so glad my review encouraged you to read this book because it truly is a classic.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thank you. I agree. If it were a book group, views could get much more specific. I’m so glad I read your thoughts too. I think I’d ordered a copy within a day or so
LikeLiked by 1 person
This is so compelling and complex, isn’t it. I read it a while ago and must watch the film some time soon.
LikeLiked by 1 person
It is, indeed. Such a surprise to see all of those layers when one was expecting it to focus on one theme mostly.
LikeLike
The ending is a real puzzle. I went back to the start and read the first chapter again, then read the ending again, and still couldn’t quite decide which way to jump, so to speak. I appreciated that both possibilities were possible.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I was fairly sure when I first read the ending, of one possibility, then when I reread it, I wondered again.
LikeLike
Yes, and I’m still wondering! I love that about an ambigious ending.
LikeLike